The Arnhem White Villa Murder – A Miscarriage of Justice?

The Story Behind a Case Marked by Coerced Confessions and Missing Evidence

How Nine Men Were Convicted Without Evidence – And Why Doubt Still Remains

Scales of justice and gavel on law book – Credit Photo tomloel DepositPhotos

Page Description

The 1998 Arnhem White Villa murder led to nine convictions without solid evidence. Explore why many now question the verdict and call for justice.

Reconstructie villamoord

Back to menu

18 sep 2018
 
ARNHEM – Het onderzoek naar de Arnhemse Villamoord moet worden overgedaan. Dat adviseert de advocaat-generaal aan de Hoge Raad. Uit onderzoek blijkt dat negen mannen zijn veroordeeld op basis van bekentenissen die zeer vermoedelijk vals zijn. Als dit bewijs wegvalt, is dit de grootste gerechtelijke dwaling die ons land heeft gekend.

1 Ton Derksen over de Arnhemse Villamoord in de Week van Gelderland

 

21 sep. 2018

– Komt er na twintig jaar uitsluitsel in de Arnhemse Villamoord? Het onderzoek naar de moord op de 63-jarige bewoonster van de villa in Arnhem in 1998 moet over. Mogelijk zaten 9 veroordeelden onterecht vast, een van hen pleegde zelfs zelfmoord in zijn cel. In de Week van Gelderland liet wetenschapsfilosoof Ton Derksen zijn licht schijnen over de zaak. ‘Die mannen hebben gewoon niets gedaan.’

2 Maker Joost van Wijk, advocaat Paul Acda en nabestaan Mariëlla Sneep over docuserie ‘Villamoord’

14 jan. 2020

 
‘De Villamoord’ is een driedelige documentaireserie van de KRO-NCRV over de ‘Arnhemse villamoord’, mogelijk de grootste gerechtelijke dwaling in de Nederlandse geschiedenis. Vanavond is documentairemaker Joost van Wijk te gast om te praten over deze onthullende documentaire, samen met advocaat Paul Acda en Mariëlla Sneep. Haar broer werd veroordeeld in deze zaak maar hij hield altijd vol onschuldig te zijn.

3 ‘Essentiële bron verzwegen in zaak Arnhemse villamoord’

14 jan. 2020

ARNHEM – De politie en het Openbaar Ministerie hebben een essentiele bron verzwegen in de zaak van de Arnhemse Villamoord, eind jaren 90. Dat blijkt uit een documentaire die de KRO-NCRV deze week uitzendt. Negen mannen zaten mogelijk jarenlang onterecht in de cel voor de moord.

4 Arnhemse Villamoord moet worden herzien’

17 jan. 2014

‘Arnhemse Villamoord moet worden herzien’

5 de witte villa moord deel 1

Back to menu

13 dec 2023

6 de witte villa moord deel 2

Back to menu

13 dec 2023

7 de witte villa moord deel 3

Back to menu

 
13 dec 2023
🔍 Key Facts & Timeline
  • Date & Location: On 2 September 1998, a violent armed robbery occurred in a villa (known as the “Witte Villa”) in Arnhem. A 63-year-old woman was shot dead and her 33-year-old friend was severely wounded ▶ reddit.com+12eenvandaag.avrotros.nl+12gelderlander.nl+12.

  • Convictions: Nine men—mostly of Turkish-Dutch origin—were arrested and convicted based almost entirely on confessions. These confessions are now widely considered to have been coerced. Sentences ranged from 5 to 12 years; one defendant later died by suicide in prison. ▶ eenvandaag.avrotros.nl

  • Lack of Forensic Evidence: No murder weapon was ever found, and there was no DNA, fingerprints, or credible eyewitness testimony linking the men to the crime scene ▶ .

  • Pressure & Coercion: Investigations later revealed the police had used intense interrogation tactics—feeding suspect details and exerting psychological pressure—to elicit confessions. Independent experts reviewed over 160 hours of police footage and identified serious misconduct. ▶ documentairenet.nl

  • Call for Review & Official Opinion: In 2018, the Adviescommissie Afgesloten Strafzaken (ACAS) recommended re-examining forensic evidence. They stated that if no new evidence emerges, the case should be fully reopened, calling it “possibly the greatest judicial error in Dutch history.” The Attorney General supported these recommendations ▶ documentairenet.nl+4eenvandaag.avrotros.nl+4robscholtemuseum.nl+4.


📺 In Media & Public Debate
  • Documentary “De Villamoord”: A multi-part KRO‑NCRV series (2020) revisiting the case, drawing parallels to other infamous judicial errors in the Netherlands. It highlighted how police questioning shaped confessions and downplayed alternative theories ▶ nu.nl+7documentairenet.nl+7robscholtemuseum.nl+7.

  • Scholarly & Legal Consensus: Legal experts and researchers, including those from Maastricht University, have called the case a more severe miscarriage of justice than even the Puttense moordzaak, marking it as a “school example” of coerced confessions ▶ reddit.com+6eenvandaag.avrotros.nl+6crimesite.nl+6.


✅ Current Status
  • The case has not been officially reopened yet.

  • Forensic evidence (DNA/fingerprints) is currently undergoing re-examination.

  • A new revision request is in process, and many see this case as emblematic of systemic failures involving forced confessions and investigative bias.

Exploding Canon Ball Prank

Back to menu

Keeping Up Appearances – Looking at Properties – S04 E05 Part 01

Back to menu

 
12 aug 2024
 
A policeman arrives to inform Hyacinth that her senile Daddy has been kept at the police station for patrolling the town hall with a bayonet. She sends Richard (heavily disguised) to retrieve him while she goes to look at country properties with Elizabeth, but Richard is terrified that she’ll get carried away and buy something they cannot afford.